31-12-2012, 01:09 AM
Hi RJ,
I did not participate in your poll, because I consider it quite useless. If I'd voted "Good", what would you gain from that? To me, the value of this forum lies in discovering alternative motivations, visions and ways of execution, and understanding what works when, with what and why. "Good" does not tell you anything about any of these.
Fact is: after a brief listen and without examining the multitracks or the other mixes much, I find your mix very solid in almost every respect. I think i understand what you mean by 'natural', and I think you accomplished a good bit of it -- within the boundaries set by the raw material. My only complaint at this point is that the drums 'click' too much in the 6.5 kHz region.
Thanks for sharing your mix!
Marc
I did not participate in your poll, because I consider it quite useless. If I'd voted "Good", what would you gain from that? To me, the value of this forum lies in discovering alternative motivations, visions and ways of execution, and understanding what works when, with what and why. "Good" does not tell you anything about any of these.
Fact is: after a brief listen and without examining the multitracks or the other mixes much, I find your mix very solid in almost every respect. I think i understand what you mean by 'natural', and I think you accomplished a good bit of it -- within the boundaries set by the raw material. My only complaint at this point is that the drums 'click' too much in the 6.5 kHz region.
Thanks for sharing your mix!
Marc