I'm never gonna love live recordings ;)

[Krabbe]

Thanks for your input

I thought about the panning of the guitar - and the mandolin - because it's the only instrument, so it's natural to have it there. Then I thought that I love playing air drums when listening to music, so I decided to make the panning as if I were behind the drums, so you've got the guitar slighty right and the mandolin slighty left. To even it out, I sent their respective verbs to the opposite side ... just for the fun of it.

I considered thinning the guitar further, but I didn't because it's far from a busy mix and it's the only instrument providing notes for the vocals, so I decided that it was ok if it had a little more weight.

Sounds great. No real issues. I don't love the vocal tone but that's on the mic. You've dealt with it well.

I, too, am a fan of panning but the electric guitar has so much "weight" that it pull my attention to the right. I think if it were centered it'd support the vocal more. It probably could use a little more thinning as well, regardless of where it's panned. Either to limit its gravity to the right or to give room for the vocal if centered. It might be less of an issue over speakers as opposed to headphones.

Other than that it all seems to work. I like the BgVs, the snare and bass especially. Good job.