28-03-2020, 08:26 PM
(26-03-2020, 10:05 AM)Krabbe Wrote: Hi
Overall it's a nice mix, it's well balanced and pleasant to listen to.
I like panning, but considering there only guitar and a little mandolin, maybe I think that hard panning's a little too aggressive?
The vocals could need more work. Her vocal is oddly thin and the background vocals are a bit too pulled back.
Well done.
Thank you for the critique. Especially the panning. You are right on. It doesn't really make sense. I wanted to stay away from a monoish mix. I did a short filtered echo of the guitar and panned it pretty hard right to make it feel less disconnected. However, the mandolin is kinda on its own island. It should be mostly centered with Amy. I will take another shot at it in a few days. I will address the panning, Amy's tone and the backing vocals. Thank you for taking the time to listen and write your thoughts. -BP